Helping Your Rescue Dog Feel Comfortable With a New Pet Sitter

A rescue dog can cope with a new sitter, but not by surprise. Two visits before the first stay changes almost everything.

By Mary E., Rover pet sitter in Deerfield Beach, FL · Updated 2 Oct 2026 · 3 min read

Change is the thing anxious dogs handle worst, and a stay with a sitter is a lot of change at once: a new house, a new person, a new routine, and you gone. None of that has to be a crisis, but it does have to be planned.

Mary E., a Rover pet sitter in Deerfield Beach, takes nervous and rescue dogs for boarding and day care. This is the sequence that gives them the best chance.

Quick answers

Should a rescue dog meet the sitter before the stay?

Yes, at least once, ideally twice, at the sitter's home with the owner present. A second visit without the owner, for an hour, is the best test.

Should I do a trial night?

For a nervous dog, yes. One night, or a day of day care, tells you how the dog copes and gives the sitter real information before a long trip.

What should I send with an anxious dog?

The usual food, any medication, a bed or blanket, an unwashed t-shirt that smells of home, and one familiar toy. Familiar smell is more calming than anything else you can pack.

Will my rescue dog be worse after the stay?

Not if the routine is kept and nobody new is introduced. Dogs that regress usually did so because the stay was chaotic, they were left alone a lot, or visitors came and went.

What if my dog will not settle with anyone else?

Some dogs do best with a drop-in sitter coming to their own home, so the environment stays the same. That is the case for cats and for some anxious dogs. Ask about it before you book.

Before the stay: two visits

Visit one. Meet the sitter at their home with your dog on a lead. Stay 20 to 30 minutes, mostly in silence. Let your dog explore.
Visit two. Leave the dog with the sitter for about an hour while you go for a coffee. Ask for a photo. This is the real test.
A short day of day care. If it went well, book half a day before the overnight so the dog has already done a full leave and return.

Keep everything identical

Same food, same bowl, same feed times.
Same walk times and routes where possible.
Same sleeping arrangement: if the dog sleeps in the bedroom at home, ask for the same.
Same cues and words, written down on the routine sheet.
Same rules: if the dog is not allowed on furniture, or has to wait before eating, say so.

Manage the sitter's household

Ask that no visitors come while your dog is there.
Ask how many other dogs will be present, and whether your dog can be the only pet.
Ask that the sitter does not take your dog to busy places.
Ask for daily updates at a fixed time, so you are not guessing.

The handover

Hand over the bag and the routine sheet in one go, keep the goodbye short, and do not come back for one more hug. For a dog who finds change hard, a clean break is kinder than two. Ask for a photo within the first couple of hours so you know the dog came out from behind the sofa.

When drop-in visits are the better fit

If your dog cannot settle away from home, or if you have cats, a drop-in sitter who visits your home is often the least stressful choice. Your dog keeps the whole environment, the smells and the routine, and only has to cope with a new person for an hour at a time.

Need a Deerfield Beach pet sitter?

Mary E. boards dogs in her home in Deerfield Beach, takes doggy day care, and does drop-in visits for cats. She has 10 years of experience, a 5.0 rating across 34 Rover reviews and 8 repeat clients. New Rover customers get $20 off through her link.

Check Mary's dates on Rover

Booking, messaging and payment happen on Rover. This site never asks for your details.